Some are praising Canadian Prime Minister, Mark Carney, as well as Kier Starmer and Emmanuel Macron, for saying they will recognize Palestine as a state. For Starmer, it is conditional on Israel agreeing to a ceasefire. If it does, the UK will back down once again and allow Israel to continue its colonial project. But anyone who has followed this issue for any length of time understands how untruthful and unrealistic this proposal is, when one considers the facts on the ground.
Israel has steadily stolen land from historic Palestine since the Nakba in 1948, when Zionist militias violently expelled Palestinians from their lands. In fact, Gaza is largely made up of refugees who suffered from this blatant act of ethnic cleansing. After dismantling its illegal settlements in Gaza in 2005, it blockaded the enclave up to the present day, trapping over 2 million people in a concentration camp where food was restricted and where they were routinely bombed and surveilled by the Israeli occupation forces.
Israel has funded and supported illegal settlements in the occupied West Bank for decades which has carved up the territory into isolated islands. Palestinians there have been terrorized by violent settlers for years. Separated from their farmlands and other villages by checkpoints and walls. Forced to use separate roads from Jewish Israelis. Subjected to military tribunal, night raids, random abductions and pogroms led by settlers and protected by the IDF.
So, what will this Palestinian “state” look like? Israel has already said it would not recognize a Palestinian state. But even if it did, it would be an ungovernable group of Bantustans. And Israel would still enforce its will over the land and the skies. Is this what they mean by sovereignty?
The two state “solution” has always been a lie. It has always been a way to justify colonial dispossession of the Palestinians. Since its founding, Israel has been illegal. It has no right to the land. And its construction of an elaborate apartheid system that rivels apartheid South Africa is a testament to this. The international players, which operate from the mindset of European colonial empire, have used this supposed “peace process” as a ruse to allow Israel to complete its own colonial settler project.
Let’s be clear, Carney and the other European leaders do not care about the mass murder of civilians in Gaza by the Israeli and American regimes. They care about their reputations and the very real possibility that they will be found complicit in this genocide. After all, it took them nearly two years to finally make a peep. Two years of carpet bombing, shootings of toddlers and mass starvation. Two years of complete destruction of hospitals, bakeries, shelters, universities and nearly every structure in the enclave. Two years of Israeli politicians and media openly using genocidal rhetoric. Two years of Israeli soldiers brazenly posting their crimes online for all to see. And it was the most feeble and mealymouthed peep imaginable.
It is time for the two state lie to be buried in the dustheap of history where it belongs. The only solution is a one state solution. And this is not a pipedream. Israel and Palestine are already one state. An apartheid state that is engaging in genocide of its indigenous population. The solution is to end this genocide and dismantle the infrastructure of apartheid. The solution is for there to be a reckoning for war criminals and genocidaires. For a Truth and Reconciliation process. And for all residents of historic Palestine to have full citizenship with equal rights. The solution is for Western political leaders to finally listen to their own constituents and end this charade once and for all. Anything less than this is a cynical ploy aimed at whitewashing the political image of the few, while millions of people stand on the precipice of annihilation.
Kenn Orphan, July 2025
