The Madness of Fascism is the Point

Like many of you, I watch the implosion of the United States in horror. It seems like madness. And on one level, it is. But on another, it is not. What I mean by the latter is that what is happening isn’t some random craziness. It is a calculated plan. It is the “tear it all down in order to build it up” approach, similar to how other fascist and authoritarian regimes operate.

These regimes see any democratic institution as an impediment to the glory of the state or the empire. Consolidation of power is viewed as the only way forward for saving it. Thus, the oligarch Elon Musk has been tasked with the unraveling. He has been given the keys to the kingdom. And like a petulant and sociopathic child, he has gone inside, turned over the crockery, fired all the servants and dumped out the treasure chest.

And this brings me to the Maga phenomenon. Because this is the heart of this particular iteration of fascism. “Make America Great Again” is of course a silly and sophomoric bit of nonsense. Which era of “greatness” do they mean? Indigenous genocide? Slavery? Lynching? Jim Crow? Red Scare? Bombing dozens of nations?

In reality, the only “great” part of America has been the magnitude of its scope, scale and power. If there is any noble greatness, it has come from its oppressed peoples. From Indigenous, Black, Brown, working class women, LGBTQ, and other marginalized communities who resisted the brutality of the American boot on their necks. Certainly not the ruling class that runs corporations and both political parties.

To the leadership of this cult of Maga, it is not only about demonizing, otherizing, scapegoating and persecuting anyone who is not white, cis-male, Christian, capitalist and heterosexual. This part is an essential characteristic of fascistic rule. But it is also about bullying the vassal and client states of the American Empire into submission. It knows it can’t do this with its own oligarchy, so it focuses on tributes, concessions and relinquishing of territory from rivals and allies. Its “great” past was one brimming in arrogant and unmerciful dominance. And this is the one they want to return to.

The problem is that the world is different now. The American Empire is in steep decline. Its prominence and prestige are waning. Even its vaunted dollar is increasingly tenuous. The unilateral hegemony it once knew is crumbling while other empires and coalitions rise. So, it is doing what all dying empires do. It installed a madman to restore its greatness.

And we should not think this madman is holding the US hostage. His approval rating among Americans has been mostly positive in these first few weeks. He embodies the very worst characteristics of the American stereotype. He is boorish, intolerant, anti-intellectual, averse to facts, arrogant and ruthless. And he is admired for this. This should not be surprising as all fascist leaders share similar traits and they enjoy cultish devotion because of them.

The problem with madmen is that they have a tendency to burn things down far greater than they build or rebuild things. And once fascism makes a home in a country it becomes exceedingly difficult to remove it. 

Kenn Orphan, February 2025

*title image is from the Holocaust Memorial Museum in Washington, DC.

Trump’s plan for Gaza is in keeping with American Tradition

So, Trump wants the US to “take over” Gaza. And he isn’t opposed to using American troops to make that happen. That is all over the news today. Trump is being essentially the scrubby New York real estate dealer that he is. He sees this as a sweet deal. “We’ll make it the Riviera of the Middle East,” he said.

He isn’t troubled by the bodies under the rubble or the half-starved population still there. He spoke unemotionally about forcibly relocating over a million people. Unspoken were the hundreds of thousands of Gazans now gone from the equation. A genocide not spoken of in polite society. “Why would they want to return?” he asked, “the place has been hell”. He described their predicament as if it were a natural disaster. As if their suffering were caused by some tsunami or monsoon and not by the bombs and drones and snipers supplied by the world’s most powerful nation under an administration run by a Democrat.

The shift comes as a shock to many, as US official policy has always aimed for a two-state solution. Anyone who has followed this issue closely has understood this has always been a farce, one repeated by both Democratic and Republican regimes alike for decades, even as they bolstered the settler-colonial project that is Israel. The Palestinians have always represented a thorn in this project’s side. A problem to placate and pacify with endless amounts of platitudes and apartheid, promises and brutality. And it all ended where it was destined to end, in genocide.

Trump’s plan isn’t really that shocking when one considers that the American project, itself, has always been a real estate deal. It has always framed the living earth as a commodity to be bought, developed ruthlessly, then sold to the highest bidder. In this worldview, land is not something to be cherished. No tree is sacred, as the olive tree is to the Palestinians. It holds no existential weight. It is not beloved even though it freights our souls through this vast galaxy. It is a monetized unit of wealth to be wrapped up tightly in plastic and shipped over night to the consumer.

This is America at its rancid heart. A project that slaughtered millions of buffalo to stick it to the Indigenous people of the land. That enslaved millions of Africans to harvest cotton. That nuked two civilian populations, the only nation to do so thus far. That doused thousands of hectares of farmland and rainforest in Southeast Asia with napalm and agent orange. That scorched the deserts of Iraq and Afghanistan to avenge a crime they had nothing to do with.

A nation that gleefully blows off the tops of ancient mountains in Appalachia for a few buckets of coal. That sullies the groundwater for a few gasps of “natural” gas. That digs its pincers into marshland to suck out the last bits of the earth’s primordial blood. And which has belched out the most warming gasses into our atmosphere of all nation states thus far.

Trump’s plan for Gaza is in keeping with this tradition. It is disaster capitalism at its zenith. And it is in keeping with how the American project views the living mantel of this planet. The life-giving loam that we all depend upon. It is in keeping with how it sees its Indigenous peoples. A problem to be dealt with by administering the appropriate, surgical military strikes accompanied with a boatload of platitudes. A minor bump in the road on the way to development.

Gaza is a mirror. And it is staring back at us all. It is the modern manifestation of a long, bloody legacy of colonial greed, exploitation and cruelty. And like all other stolen lands, it will not cease to exist just because its buildings and orchards and people were mercilessly leveled or because some greasy real estate dealer now has his eyes set on it.

Kenn Orphan, February 2025

*Title piece is a painting by the Palestinian artist, Heba Zagout. Heba was killed along with her children in an airstrike on their home in Gaza in October, 2023.

Above All, Love Fiercely

We all woke up to a different world today. One where dehumanizing language and threats from a American president are being applauded. Where a Nazi salute at its inauguration is being normalized or played down. And no matter how some may gaslight you or attempt to normalize it, the fact is that the world we woke up to today is a terrifying one. And it is okay to feel that. To feel terrified about what is to come. If you aren’t, I would question your sanity. But know you aren’t alone in that fear.

The United States has fallen to authoritarianism. Bolder than anyone has seen in the States thus far. Of course, the seeds of it were always there. An undercurrent simmering for decades. Supremacist mythology and obtuse indifference. Political leaders who became more and more corrupt, beholden to corporate and militaristic hubris. Who openly aided a genocide. Rights systematically striped away. Education and intellectualism mocked relentlessly. A persistent and influential religious fundamentalism. An oligarchy that grew more and more powerful, year after year. The result of these things was inevitable: Fascism.

But we cannot afford to ignore the writing on the wall. The US is an empire in decline. Burning or flooded cities thanks to the unaddressed impacts of climate change, growing shantytowns, entrenched poverty. Stagnant services and crumbling infrastructure. A predatory healthcare system. A bloated and over-extended military.

America is a sinking ship. And it has placed a fascist in the captain’s seat. And these facts make it even more dangerous than before, not only to marginalized people in the States, but to anyone in its orbit. And let’s face it. We are ALL in its orbit.

So, what do we do now? In the short term, it is okay to hide. To distract ourselves. We may need to do this for our sanity and physical health. But in the long term, denial can be lethal. It can strip us of our agency, Our capacity to act. So, after a time, it may be necessary for you to act quickly and decisively.

If you are in the States, I would seriously consider leaving. If you cannot leave, I would consider relocating to a state with more progressive governance. I understand moving may be economically impossible for many. And some may not want to leave family. If you cannot leave your state, seek out like minded individuals and organizations. Believe me, they exist. And you will all need each other in the coming years. Build networks for assistance and protection. Reliable support for when the government is potentially denuded of its ability to provide assistance.

If you are outside the US, avoid all unnecessary travel to it. Begin untethering yourself from its orbit. Voice your dissent and object to policies that seek to normalize relations with the States. Elect leaders who will stand up to American imperialism.

No matter where you live, consider becoming active in local politics. Attend meetings or hearings. The biggest impact we can have is on the local level.

Take a good look at how and where you live and who you know. Identify individuals and organizations that seek to dehumanize, demonize or criminalize you and avoid them. The history of fascism is a history of betrayal. Hold your enemies at bay. And know who your allies are and hold them close. Solidarity is not a platitude. It is a survival skill.

Above all, love fiercely. Love is the best antidote to fascism. To its fear, its cruelty, its violence. Love with everything you’ve got.

Kenn Orphan, January 2025

*Photo is Metamorphosis by Joan Miró, 1935.

Resist, Defend, Love

Watching the fires in Los Angeles last night, I sat back and thought about this last year. I lived most of my adult life in Southern California. I know how it changed over the years. How the fire season became a year round event. And I was flooded with a deep sense of dread.

I couldn’t shake the feeling that this was a harbinger. That we are entering a new Dark Age. I can feel it in my skin. In my blood. In my bones. Maybe you can too. But we are constantly told to practice wellness. To be inured to the madness. The ecological devastation. The violence. The unraveling.

I thought about watching a genocide being livestreamed on my Instagram. The firebombing of children. Of the elderly. Of the sick. In hospitals in Gaza. Scorched earth, just as in Los Angeles. And the starvation. The humiliation. The annihilation. Funded by our tax dollars. All coupled with a kind of numbing agent, as if I was sitting in a chair at the dentist office waiting for a tooth to be pulled.

“It’s all ok. Make sure to practice self-care. You are doom scrolling too much!” The messaging seems constant.

Yet, everything feels surreal. As if we are in an AI generated reality. And we seem to accept it all through a tyranny of miniature screens we hold closest to our skin. Closer than we hold actual humans or animals. Closer than we hold ourselves.

We are in a different world now. A world rapidly devolving. Climate change, fascism, and the predations of late capitalism. A world where nonsense is elevated. AI generated content is taken as truth. Where starving or burning children alive is normalized. Where the unhoused and the poor are criminalized. Where the marginalized are easily dehumanized. Where billionaires are viewed as demigods. But even the billionaires are running now as their mansions are devoured by an angry earth. Oh, how the gods fall before us.

And the rise of one man to the seat of power in the strongest empire the world has ever seen is ushering in an age of chaos. Because that is what he does best. He brings chaos. He is already doing that and he isn’t even in office.

I keep seeing people say that “it will be a long four years.” And my response is no, my friend, it won’t.

I have come to believe that his ascent to the throne of American Empire signifies the beginning of the end for organized human civilization on this planet. It isn’t he that is bringing this to us. He is merely a symbol of our age. An emblem of narcissistic privilege. A personified and collective id we are afraid to acknowledge.

Hyperbolic? Maybe. But the so-called Doomsday Clock devised by concerned scientists puts us closer to the midnight hour than ever before. And what do we get in response? Lies and bromides. Platitudes and veiled threats. But the veil has been slipping for some time now.

I hope I am wrong. I really do. And I will celebrate my wrongness. But I’ve seen nothing to change my mind thus far.

Resist. Defend. Love. For some reason, these words keep repeating in my mind.

And I guess that is because, at this point, it is literally all we have left to us.

Kenn Orphan, January 2025

*Photo is a satellite image of the fires in Los Angeles.

Anatomy of a Hero

Apparently, there is some confusion over the politics of Luigi Mangione, the alleged assassin of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson. This is largely because his politics do not seem to align with the approved framework for today’s arrangement of power. They are messy. Because we live in messy times. Confused times. But this isn’t as bizarre or problematic as some would make it out to be. And anyone who has been traumatized is a victim of these messy, confusing times.

The reality is that he fits the archetype of hero. Not in a romanticized or sentimental way. Not in the Hollywood manner which infantilizes the very concept of hero with cheap nationalistic tropes, hyper-masculine numbness, or superhuman capabilities. He is a hero because, like all heroes, his life was scarred by trauma and unfathomable pain. Like all heroes, he has stepped out the shadows of deep, systemic injustice in our times to make a stand, however flawed, against this injustice. Like all heroes, he is misunderstood, maligned and demonized by the rich and powerful and celebrated by the oppressed, the lower caste, the underdog. He represents the latter’s disappointment and rage, and he channeled that rage into action, albeit misguided.

You don’t have to understand or agree with all of his political opinions to understand that he emerged from the pathos of an age where a group of wealthy businessmen have arisen to extract extraordinary wealth from the denial of medical assistance to millions of sick or injured people. An age of sheer barbarity, where life saving or pain-alleviating treatments and medications are only available to those who have the ability to pay exorbitant fees. An age where a small class of people, propelled by avarice and cupidity, enjoy pampered and untroubled lives of luxury via the siphoning of wealth from the vast working class who suffer daily indignities at their hand.

The assassination of Brian Thompson made clear that if you’re poor and murdered there’ll likely be no manhunt mounted for your killer or any blanket media coverage of the incident that could ever compare with what we’ve seen this past week. This one fact alone highlights the vast inequities within American society. It goes beyond healthcare. The justice system, the media, the whole system is unequal, unfair and staggeringly cruel. Far more cruel than any action allegedly taken by Luigi Mangione.

Heroes don’t always save people’s physical lives. In fact, they seldom do. Heroes save our humanity by showing the wealthy and the powerful that our lives have meaning, that we are enraged by the inequality, cruelty and injustice that they profit from, and that we are not going silently into the night as they would have us do.

Kenn Orphan, December 2024

*Photo is of alleged shooter, Luigi Nicholas Mangione.

America’s Own Pinochet

When Americans are told that fascism is coming to the United States, there is often a misconception of what that actually means. Imagery of jackbooted thugs in 1930s Germany come to mind. Hollywood has been good in casting all fascist authoritarianism in Hitlerian ways. But this can have the effect of inuring the public to fascism in their own society because they are looking for a fascism that resembles that of Hitler. Fascism has similar characteristics, but manifests differently depending on the society in which it arises.

Hitler wasn’t the only fascist and fascism doesn’t always mean mass extermination of millions of people of a particular group. Violence, persecution and threats can be just as effective for fascists to maintain power. Fascism is unlike any other political ideology. It is neither traditionally conservative or liberal, but it always emerges from the far-right. At its most basic, fascism can be more accurately understood as a cult of personality and power that successfully entrances a segment of society while terrorizing the rest into submission. It relies on reactionary or conservative notions of society, but it is an undemocratic cult that cannot be reasoned with in any way.

Augusto Pinochet, the fascist dictator of Chile from 1973-1990, who got into power thanks to an American orchestrated coup once said: “Not a single leaf moves in this country if I’m not the one moving it.” He meant this. He saw himself as a savior of the nation. And he acted with ruthless cruelty to make this cultish fantasy a reality.

I have often compared Donald Trump to Pinochet which may sound strange to some. Pinochet was a general. He was embedded in militarism. But the two men share many traits when it comes to power, narcissism and violent rhetoric. Similar to Pinochet, Trump once said he was the “only one to fix the nation.” He is even more emboldened with a sense of divine purpose after surviving assassination attempts. Now that Trump has been elected (again), I believe he will implement similar measures and policies as Pinochet, or perhaps even worse. So, if Americans aren’t afraid of what is to come, they should be.

Fascism has always been an undercurrent in American society, a nation founded upon a graveyard of Indigenous people wiped out by genocide or persecuted and forcibly removed from their lands. And was built by the hands of enslaved men, women and children from Africa. It never reconciled with this past. Fascism has always been a consistent thread that binds America’s aspirations to its obfuscation about the atrocities it has committed. But now fascism is no longer cloaked in the euphemisms and platitudes of its aristocracy. Its so-called exceptionalism or democratic ideals. The cloak has been ripped off and torn to shreds.

Some have suggested that the oligarchies of the US would never allow Trump to make sweeping changes to the republic. This is ahistorical at best, and toxic naivete at worst. The wealthy in Pinochet’s Chile did nothing to subvert him or his violent and brutal policies. Corporations, including many American ones, flourished. Shopping malls and the latest trends were common in the upper class neighborhoods of Santiago. The press was effectively muzzled. Pinochet infamously said that the “rich people create wealth, so you have to treat them well so that they continue to give wealth.”

Under Pinochet, thousands of people were “disappeared” many never to be recovered. Dropped into the sea, buried in forests. Thousands of so-called “enemies from within” were massacred. And tens of thousands more were terrorized and tortured. We had a glimpse of this playbook when it was replayed under the previous Trump administration at protests in Portland. Scores were whisked away in unmarked vehicles by government agents with no badges visible.

In his second term, Trump has promised to round up millions of immigrants for deportation. He has also vowed to send troops into “Democratic cities” and deal with the so-called “enemy from within.” We can draw clear conclusions of what that will look like. Millions of immigrants would have to be housed in concentration camps, a plan almost half of Americans support according to a recent poll. And the “enemy from within” would almost certainly include anyone who dissents, whether they do so for queer or trans rights, to protest US support for Israel as it commits genocide, or any other group deemed subversive or “undesirable.”

Pinochet was quick to use the most conservative elements of the Catholic Church in Chile to bolster his anti-Marxist crusade. In a similar way, Trump uses evangelical, fundamentalist and other Christo-fascist elements in society to further his dominance by appearing empathetic to their bigotry against transgender people. And he lends credence to their unhinged conspiracy theories and end times cosplay about Israel. Trump has already made messianic-like claims after surviving assassination attempts. And there are scores of fanatical Christians who are eager to frame in this way. The telltale signs of cultish adoration are more than apparent in these circles.

Pinochet also once said: “My library is filled with UN condemnations” and “The only solution to the issue of human rights is oblivion.” I could picture Trump saying something similar, and this is an ominous clue as to how he will likely treat the unhoused, women, Muslims, immigrants, queer and other vulnerable communities, as well as how he will proceed on the genocide in Gaza.

In addition to all of this, Trump will likely speed humanity and countless other species closer to annihilation from climate change and ecological degradation. Not that the corporate Democrats would have been much better, but we might have had a bit more time to act. Time to mitigate the damage from coming catastrophes. We have absolutely no time now.

One of the differences between the rise of Pinochet vs the rise of Trump is that the US was largely responsible for Pinochet’s success as a dictator. In Trump’s case, there are many other factors, including the egregious tactics of the Democratic Party and their continued disinterest in the working class. They offered no meaningful policy to help struggling Americans, courted celebrities and neocon politicians like Liz Cheney, and ignored the overwhelming call of its base for an arms embargo on Israel as it commits genocide. One could say that there were foreign influences on the campaign, but these were negligible.

Another factor is Trump’s appeal to Gen Z men, mostly white, who feel disaffected and alienated from any agency or meaning. They have become fertile ground for racist and incel propaganda. And they came out to support what they see as a sort of father figure. A man who actually listens to them, rather than chides them with remarks like “I’m speaking.”

I wish I had brighter words. I wish I could tell us all to hope. To protest. But a Trump regime is likely to crack down viciously and violently on all dissent and protest. Fascists don’t care about the pretense of democratic norms. To them, they are an unnecessary impediment. The cult is supreme in fascist regimes. Challenging it in any way is viewed as an existential threat and dealt with accordingly.

All we can do now is take a good look at our lives. Where we live. Who we love. The social, ecological and economic fabric we are connected to. The most vulnerable among us. And protect them from the hell that is undoubtedly coming. We need to act. To organize with others. To make changes to our lives if we must. Changes that might appear overwhelming, but that have been made countless times throughout history. To move. To build resilient, interdependent communities. And we must do this because it is literally all we have left.

Kenn Orphan, November 2024

*Photo is of the US backed coup in Chile in 1973 which installed the fascist dictator Augusto Pinochet.

On the 11 September 1973, right-wing general Augusto Pinochet launched a coup against the elected left-wing government in Chile of Salvador Allende. Pinochet had been appointed by Allende as head of his armed forces the previous month, and used the position to orchestrate the coup.
On day one, the new government began rounding up thousands of people – mostly working class activists and left-wingers – in the national stadium, killing many. The brutal military dictatorship, which was backed by western powers like the US and UK, implemented the harsh right-wing economic ideology of the neoliberal Chicago Boys.
While international observers heralded the resultant “economic miracle”, in reality living standards declined for the vast majority of the population, with wages falling and spending on healthcare, education and housing being cut.
Any workers who attempted to resist were murdered, tortured, imprisoned or “disappeared”. A popular method of execution by the regime was to throw civilians to their deaths from helicopters into the ocean or over the Andes mountains. Many of the alt right today celebrate these murders with “helicopter memes”.
Over the next 17 years, more than 3,000 people were murdered by the regime, with more than 37,000 others illegally imprisoned or tortured. Many prisoners, men and women, were systematically raped and sexually abused by guards, with women a particular target. In addition to being violated by guards, some women were sexually assaulted with dogs, rats and spiders, and forced to have sex with male family members. Many children of those killed were given to the Catholic church, or adopted, with the children either not informed or told their parents had died in accidents. 

Along with Bombs, Starvation and Torture, Israel is Burning Civilians to Death

The young man on the right was Sha’ban Al Dalou. He is pictured here with his family and was a 19 year old software engineering student who spoke fluent English. He was trying to raise money to get his family evacuated from Northern Gaza to Egypt. But that never happened.

Israel murdered him along with his family this past weekend in the meager tent he had built for his family next to Al Aqsa hospital with a 2 ton American-made bomb. His last moments were captured of him in the flames on a cot with an IV still in his arm.

I will never forget that video. I will never forget the screams or the wailing. And even though I have seen a lot horror and brutality in my lifetime, I will never be the same after this one year.

Explain to me how this was self-defense. Explain to me how Western politicians can still call this a “humanitarian crisis” and not what it is: genocide. Explain how a year can go by, with thousands upon thousands of civilians dead, including thousands upon thousands of children. So many burned, blown up, shot by snipers in the head, buried under the rubble of their homes. So many starved. Suffocated. Deprived of life saving medical care, medications, anesthesia, polio vaccines. So many bakeries, shelters, universities, schools, hospitals, houses, churches, mosques flattened. Explain to me why I should care about election cycles, when almost all Western politicians either support this, applaud it, make excuses for it, or are silent. Explain why the US and Germany are still providing 99% of the bombs and armaments to Israel and how Canada, the UK, France, Australia and other Western countries provide other arms and support. Explain why most Western media still whitewashes it all, demonizes anyone who protests, and dehumanizes the victims.

If you can explain all of this you will succeed in explaining away whatever shred is left of your humanity.

Rest in peace, Sha’ban. The world failed you, your family and your people.

Kenn Orphan, October 2024

Witness to a Nightmare

A mother sits at the bedside of her baby girl, who appears more like a skeleton than a living human child. 

A team of rescuers frantically dig through the rubble of a bombed home, hoping to find any sign of life from within. They find a cat meowing weakly. She is covered in dust, her human companions all dead, suffocated by the bricks and concrete of their home or burned slowly to death. 

A father runs screaming down the street with his son in his arms. The boy’s face is almost unrecognizable. 

A young man gingerly and with utmost reverence places a child’s head in a body bag with the rest of her remains. 

The decomposing body of a boy with Down’s syndrome who was left to starve in his home are discovered by his family after they were forced at gunpoint to leave him with assurances from soldiers that he will be taken care of. 

A six-year-old girl pleads for help on a cell phone from her family’s car. Her dead family all around her as she bleeds. A tank rolls in aiming at her. Her rescuers ambulance is bombed, and her remains are found with those of her family days later. 

This is just a fraction of what I have seen, heard, or read so far, for almost a year. 

Add to it scores of photos or videos of soldiers parading around in women’s lingerie. Women who may be dead or forced to flee for their lives. 

Soldiers playing with or smashing children’s toys, school rooms, bicycles. Children who may be dead or forced to flee for their lives. 

Soldiers dancing while they blow up shelters, hospitals, universities, mosques, churches, bakeries, water, and food supplies… 

Add to it political leaders calling for complete annihilation. Civilians blockading aid trucks. And western leaders waving a scolding finger at anyone who dare speaks out. After all, they are “speaking” and we should not “interrupt” their election cycle, steal their “joy,” lest we get an even worse leader than them. 

In my entire life, I have never seen this many children slaughtered, bombed, maimed, starved, or shot at for almost an entire year. A livestreamed genocide. The evidence is beyond clear, yet we are still being gaslit that it is self-defense. That this is about “security.” As during the war against Vietnam, we are told to disbelieve what we are witnessing because it is “tragic, but complicated.” We are shadow banned or suspended on social media for posting pictures or videos of the atrocities (one wonders how they would have censored the photo of “napalm girl”). Or told that we are bigots for wanting an immediate end to the slaughter of children, women, and men. 

We are truly witnessing a nightmare. But one without even the glimmer of morning light to give us hope. 

Kenn Orphan, September 2024 

The Racism behind the Imane Khelif Witch Hunt

The recent, manufactured controversy over Imane Khelif reminded me of a speech by the great abolitionist Sojourner Truth. She made this speech to a white audience in 1851, but the message was especially directed toward white women. In it, she describes how many Black women were subjected to heinous bigotry especially if they did not conform to a specific and narrow white standard of femininity. Sound familiar?

No woman can ever totally meet such rigid and exclusionary standards. Imane, though assigned female from birth, isn’t what many men (and sadly some women) think a woman should look like. She is strong, confident, athletic and she is competing in a sport that used to be only for men.

But we cannot ignore that Imane is a woman of colour, and how many other women of colour have faced similar attacks? The attacks on Imane are most definitely rooted in large part in a deep-seated and pernicious racism that persists to this day. Sojourner Truth’s speech is but one example of this.

Sojourner could plow a field better and eat as much as any man. She could hold her own. But this didn’t conform to the patriarchal notion of white femininity. And this is what it all comes down to. The anti-trans mob isn’t out there trying to “protect girls and women”, they are out there to police gender. They demand a ridiculous litmus test for “purity” that echoes the calls of white nationalists and other racist ideologies, and it doesn’t just negatively affect transgender women, it negatively impacts cis-women as well, as Imane has unfortunately discovered these last few weeks.

Sojourner brought the house down with this speech because, despite being discriminated against as a Black woman, she wanted to unite ALL women in solidarity to make this world a better place for everyone.

The real transcript was lost to history, but there are many reliable accounts of what she said. Here is one.

“Ain’t I a Woman?” by Sojourner Truth.

“Well, children, where there is so much racket there must be something out of kilter. I think that ‘twixt the Negroes of the South and the women at the North, all talking about rights, the white men will be in a fix pretty soon. But what’s all this here talking about?

That man over there says that women need to be helped into carriages, and lifted over ditches, and to have the best place everywhere. Nobody ever helps me into carriages, or over mud-puddles, or gives me any best place! And ain’t I a woman? Look at me! Look at my arm! I have ploughed and planted, and gathered into barns, and no man could head me! And ain’t I a woman? I could work as much and eat as much as a man – when I could get it – and bear the lash as well! And ain’t I a woman? I have borne thirteen children, and seen most all sold off to slavery, and when I cried out with my mother’s grief, none but Jesus heard me! And ain’t I a woman?

Then they talk about this thing in the head; what’s this they call it? [member of audience whispers, “intellect”] That’s it, honey. What’s that got to do with women’s rights or Negroes’ rights? If my cup won’t hold but a pint, and yours holds a quart, wouldn’t you be mean not to let me have my little half measure full?

Then that little man in black there, he says women can’t have as much rights as men, ’cause Christ wasn’t a woman! Where did your Christ come from? Where did your Christ come from? From God and a woman! Man had nothing to do with Him.

If the first woman God ever made was strong enough to turn the world upside down all alone, these women together ought to be able to turn it back , and get it right side up again! And now they is asking to do it, the men better let them.

Obliged to you for hearing me, and now old Sojourner ain’t got nothing more to say.”

*Title image is of Sojourner Truth and is courtesy of the African American History Collective.

Kenn Orphan, August 2024

My Alma Mater is closing its doors, and that is a good thing

Recently, I found out that my undergraduate alma mater is closing its doors forever. Over the past few weeks I’ve seen several social media posts from alums who seem heartbroken about it. At best, I have mixed feelings, but ultimately, I am not sad in the least.

For those who do not know, I went to Eastern Nazarene College (ENC) which was affiliated with the Nazarene denomination of protestant Christianity. It is a conservative church that had a somewhat rigid dogma and taught that dancing, going to movies, having pre-marital sex and drinking alcohol were sins and they were all forbidden activities at the college. Homosexuality was also considered a sin, although it was treated as a far more sinister thing than the others.

It may sound crazy to some that I chose to go to this kind of a school. But I went to a local Nazarene church for a few years when I was in high school and made several friends there. I was brought up in a Christian home with very loving parents, and I also considered myself a Christian. It was my experience and what I knew. So, choosing ENC wasn’t a stretch. And the fact that it was in Boston made it that much more appealing.

I attended and lived in its dormitories for four years where I had the privilege of learning from some truly terrific academics, especially my sociology professor. And I had the displeasure of being under the tutelage of some truly terrible ones, such as the head of the social work department who said that the only home she would never place a child in for foster care or adoption was one with LGBTQ+ parents. She wasn’t an outlier in her beliefs. It was part of the “holiness” culture to look down on others as not quite holy enough or as outright sinners.

I remember chatting with a guy on my dorm floor about homosexuality. When I asked him how he thought Jesus would react to a gay person, he said without hesitation that he would “turn his back on him”. I was aghast at the ease of his reply. That he found this one, so-called “sin” so much more revolting than the others. Pre-marital sex? Adultery? none of these elicited the same reaction.

At the annual Junior/Senior banquet I recall a slide show presentation of campus life put on by the seniors for the junior class, where a popular senior recounted a quip he made in philosophy class during a discussion of homosexuality. His “argument” in the debate, which he apparently found quite witty, was simply: “the anus is an exit, not an entrance”. The banquet hall erupted in laughter. This was the dehumanizing or degrading way that we were talked about, as sinister ghouls or the punchline of a crude joke.

It was at ENC where I went through one of the worst bouts of depression in my life. When I was in my freshman year I internalized the lie that I was an abomination, something heralded by the doctrine of the church. I prayed nightly for God to change me. He didn’t. And I almost didn’t survive that year.

The worst part of being at this very Christian school was that I had to hide who I was to virtually everyone, except some of my closest friends. And even with them, I was cautious. If anyone found out, I would either be expelled or be required to submit to some kind of horrid and abusive conversion “counseling” in order to remain there. This was the atmosphere of this supposedly loving place. One of isolation and fear.

But somehow in my time there I was elected president of the social work association, became co-editor of a poetry magazine, wrote editorials for the school newspaper that were most definitely considered radical or leftist, and I took part in several social justice actions against war, capitalism and environmental destruction. And this shy boy was able to delve into a love of acting and singing by joining the A Capella choir and several theatre productions of plays and musicals.

And in my senior year something changed in me spiritually and emotionally. I ceased caring about what people thought of my queerness. I took a job in Boston which thankfully got me off campus more and into an exciting city. I got my own dorm room, ditched the kitsch Christian posters and decorated it with art and more mature furnishings, bought fashionable clothes and started to feel more confident in my “worldly” worldview.

I also had my first intimate sexual experience at ENC in the privacy of my own room. It’s difficult to explain the thrill of doing something like that in defiance of an institution’s repressive rules, inhuman culture and banal medievalism. Of finally being able to be oneself. It was a beautiful experience that filled me with joy and that I revel in to this day.

After I graduated from ENC I went to a graduate school back in New York that was the polar opposite. I had professors who were bold in their social justice stances. There were no outdated paternalistic roles for genders. No one snooped into my private life or accused me of being a sinner or an abomination. And I could be completely out of the closet and celebrated for who I was. What a difference it made for the direction of my life.

As ENC closes its doors I find myself remembering those days. It’s not that I regret going there. After all, I made a lifelong friends. And I think it made me a stronger person. However I do often wonder how things might have been different for me. Would I have been able to become the person I am now much sooner? Would I have gained more confidence in myself than I do now? I’ll never know.

We are living in a time where the Queer community is under constant attack from reactionary elements in society. In the US, hundreds of laws are either on the books or are in the pipeline that blatantly discriminate against LGBTQ+ people. The rhetoric amongst conservative politicians and media personalities has become a cauldron of vicious lies and demonization. So, it is through this lens that I see ENC with a more critical eye.

ENC played a big part in shaping who I am today, but it is a chapter in my life I will gladly close forever.

Kenn Orphan, July 2024